After the closing

A title problem turned up after you bought. What does a Florida owner's policy do, and how do you make a claim?

Find your owner's title policy and give the insurer written notice promptly. The policy covers loss from title problems that already existed when you bought, such as a forged deed in the chain or an old unpaid lien, and the insurer then defends, cures, settles or pays. Problems that begin after the policy date are generally outside it.

Reviewed by Shevy Lowenstein, Florida Title Agent, License W766033November 16, 2026For homeowners, sellers, buyers and Realtors9 min readSource: Bayit Title, https://bayittitle.com/guides/title-problem-after-closing-floridaEn español

Closing on a Florida property?Get a quoteOpen an orderor call 754.253.2270

At a glance

Tell the insurer in writing, promptly, and before you pay anyone or sign anything to settle the claim.

What it covers
Title problems that already existed on the policy date
What it does not
Problems created after that date, and building and zoning law
How long it lasts
While you own the property, and after a sale for the warranties you gave
First step
Written notice to the insurer named on the policy

A question on a file of your own?

Ask us

In order

5 steps
  1. Step 1

    Find the policy

    In your closing papers, or from the title agent or attorney who closed your purchase.

  2. Step 2

    Give written notice

    Promptly, to the insurer at the address the policy gives, with what you have received.

  3. Step 3

    Settle nothing yourself

    The insurer is not liable for a settlement you make without its written consent.

  4. Step 4

    The insurer acts

    It defends a covered claim, cures the problem, settles with the claimant, or pays.

  5. Step 5

    Payment

    Within 30 days once liability and the amount of the loss are determined.

The policy form
The ALTA Owner's Policy (07-01-2021) with Florida modifications, approved by the Office of Insurance Regulation. A policy issued before Florida approved the 2021 forms is on an earlier ALTA form, worded differently in places. The policy you hold is the one that governs.
Where notice goes
To the insurer, at the address the policy gives for notices: Condition 17 on the 2021 form.
Does it expire?
No. "There is no expiration date on the owner's policy" (Florida Department of Financial Services).

This page is for an owner who has found, or been told about, a problem with the title to a Florida property they already own, and for a seller who has heard from their buyer about one. It quotes the standard owner's policy Florida approves; the policy in your hands, with its own schedules, is what decides your claim. None of it is legal advice.

What counts as a title problem, and what does not?

A title problem is a problem with who owns the property or what is recorded against it. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau puts the usual case plainly: title insurance "can protect you if someone later sues and says they have a claim against the home from before you purchased it", and the claims "could come from a previous owner's failure to pay taxes, or from contractors who say they were not paid for work done on the home before you purchased it" (CFPB).

Others that arrive after the closing:

  • someone claims to own the property, or part of it, through a deed or an inheritance;
  • a mortgage or lien from before your purchase was never released;
  • a deed in the chain turns out to have been forged, or signed by someone without authority;
  • you try to sell or borrow, and the buyer or lender is entitled to walk away because of something in the record (the policy calls this unmarketable title);
  • the record does not give you a legal right of access to the property.

What is not a title problem: the roof, the foundation, the square footage, a building permit the city never closed, and a zoning or code rule. The owner's policy excludes building and zoning law and "any discrepancy in the quantity of the area" of the land, and an open permit is a municipal record rather than something recorded against the title. What happens if there's an open permit on the property before closing?

Is it covered? The date of the policy decides

The standard owner's policy insures "as of the Date of Policy", and after it only to the extent two of its covered risks say (ALTA Owner's Policy (07-01-2021) with Florida modifications). That is the test to apply first: did the problem exist when you bought?

If it did, the covered risks reach a long way. Covered Risk 2 insures against loss from any defect in or lien or encumbrance on the title, and it includes a defect caused by "forgery, fraud, undue influence, duress, incompetency, incapacity, or impersonation", by a document "not properly authorized, created, executed, witnessed, sealed, acknowledged, notarized … or delivered", and by a document "executed under a falsified, expired, or otherwise invalid power of attorney".

If it did not, it is generally outside the policy. The same form excludes any matter "attaching or created subsequent to the Date of Policy", except under Covered Risks 9 and 10. Covered Risk 10 is the one most owners need to know about: it covers a defect, lien or encumbrance recorded after the policy date "and prior to the recording of the deed" that vested title in you, the short gap between the closing and the recording. The form also excludes anything you created, suffered, assumed or agreed to, and real estate taxes that become due after the policy date.

Then read Schedule B of your own policy. Anything listed there as an exception was taken out of the coverage before you bought, and a claim about it will be declined for that reason.

Where is your owner's policy?

In your closing papers, usually as a separate document sent after the closing. The Florida Department of Financial Services suggests keeping it with the closing disclosure, the commitment and the contract, in more than one place, and keeping "a record of the title insurance agent and agency used for the sales transaction" (DFS).

Make sure it is the owner's policy. If you borrowed, there was also a lender's policy, and it protects the lender only. Florida law requires a form telling a buyer who borrows "that the purchaser-mortgagor is not protected by the title policy of the mortgagee" (Fla. Stat. § 627.798).

If you cannot find it, ask the title agency or attorney who closed your purchase, or the insurer named on your closing statement. Florida requires the insurer to keep the title search and its determination of insurability, in its own files or its agency's, for at least 7 years after the policy was issued (Fla. Stat. § 627.7845(2)).

How do you make a claim?

Give the insurer written notice, promptly. The policy requires the insured to "notify the Company promptly in writing" on learning of "any litigation or other matter for which the Company may be liable under this policy" or of a rejection of the title as unmarketable. Late notice does not end the claim by itself; if the insurer is prejudiced by it, its liability "is reduced to the extent of the prejudice" (Condition 3).

Send it where the policy says. Notice goes to the insurer at the address the policy gives for notices (Condition 17 on the 2021 form). For a First American policy, First American's claims page takes a claim online, by email to titleclaims@firstam.com, by fax to +1 (877) 804-7606, or by mail to Attn: Title Claims, 1 First American Way, Santa Ana, CA 92707. Its National Claims Intake Center is on +1 (888) 632-1642.

Include what you have. First American asks for a copy of the policy, your name, mailing address, phone number and email, the property address (or the parcel number, where there is no street address), "a brief but detailed explanation of why you are submitting a claim", and any documents that support it. Those are whatever you have received: a letter, a lawsuit, a recorded document, a title objection from a buyer or lender.

Do not settle or pay on your own. The insurer is not liable for "liability voluntarily assumed by the Insured in settling any claim or suit without the prior written consent of the Company" (Condition 9.c). Paying a claimant to make a problem go away, before the insurer has agreed, can leave you paying it yourself.

Answer what the insurer asks. It may require a signed proof of loss describing the matter and, as far as possible, how the loss is calculated (Condition 4). The 2021 form sets no fixed number of days for it.

If you are sued, send the papers the same day. On a written request, the insurer "at its own cost and without unreasonable delay, will provide for the defense of an Insured in litigation in which any third party asserts a claim covered by this policy" (Condition 5.a). That defense is limited to the covered causes of action, and the insurer chooses the lawyer, subject to your right to object for reasonable cause.

What does the insurer do next?

It chooses among the routes the policy gives it, and it does not have to pay money if another one resolves the problem:

  • Cure it. The insurer has fully performed if it removes the defect, lien or claim, cures a lack of access, or cures unmarketable title "in a reasonable manner", and "may do so by any method, including litigation and the completion of any appeals" (Condition 9.a). It is not liable for loss from litigation until a court makes "a final, non-appealable determination adverse to the Title" (Condition 9.b).
  • Defend it, as above, or bring its own action to establish the title as insured (Condition 5).
  • Settle with the claimant, or with you, for the loss the policy covers (Condition 7.b).
  • Pay the amount of insurance, which ends its obligations under the policy, including any duty to defend (Condition 7.a).

Where it pays, it pays the lesser of the amount of insurance and "the difference between the fair market value of the Title, as insured, and the fair market value of the Title subject to the matter insured against" (Condition 8.a), measured as of the date you discover the problem (Condition 8.b). Once liability and the amount are determined, it pays "within 30 days" (Condition 12).

If you and the insurer disagree, the Florida form allows binding arbitration "only when agreed to by both the Company and the Insured" (Condition 18). On the national form either side can require it where the amount of insurance is $2,000,000 or less (ALTA Owner's Policy, 2021); Florida's modification takes that out.

You sold the house. Does the old owner's policy still matter?

It can. Coverage ends when you convey the title, with two exceptions that matter to a seller. The policy continues in your favour while you own "an obligation secured by a purchase money Mortgage given by a purchaser from the Insured", or have "liability for warranties given by the Insured in any transfer or conveyance of the Insured's Title" (Condition 2).

The second is the common one. A Florida warranty deed says the seller "does hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever" (Fla. Stat. § 689.02(1)), and a deed in that form "must be held to be a warranty deed with full common-law covenants", binding the seller and the seller's heirs (§ 689.03). If a problem from before your own purchase surfaces after you sell, a claim against you on that warranty is exactly what your policy stays alive for. And where your buyer's insurer pays your buyer's claim, the standard form makes it "subrogated and entitled to the rights and remedies" your buyer had against others (Condition 13), which can include that warranty.

So a seller who receives a demand about the title of a property they sold should send it to the insurer on their own owner's policy, the same way as an owner would.

The policy does not pass to your buyer. It "does not continue in force or effect in favor of any person or entity that is not the Insured and acquires the Title" (Condition 2). Your buyer is insured on a policy of their own.

What if the title search missed it, or there was no owner's policy?

With an owner's policy, whose fault it was is not the question. The policy is "a contract of indemnity against actual monetary loss or damage", and it says the insurer is not liable "for any claim alleging negligence or negligent misrepresentation" arising from the policy or the determination of insurability (Condition 8). A claim is decided by whether the matter is covered, not by whether anyone was careless. Before issuing the policy the insurer had to determine insurability from a reasonable search (Fla. Stat. § 627.7845(1)); what the search missed, the policy insures.

Without an owner's policy there is much less to fall back on:

  • The lender's policy protects the lender, not you.
  • The seller's deed, if it was a warranty deed, carries the covenants above, and a claim on them is a claim against a person, who may have spent the money or died.
  • A search or report bought without a policy is not insurance. Florida's property information report "does not constitute title insurance", and its issuer's liability is limited to the named recipient and "may not exceed the amount paid for the property information report" (Fla. Stat. § 627.7843).

That is the case for buying the owner's policy at the closing, cash purchase or not. Do I need owner's title insurance in Florida if I pay cash?

When should an attorney be involved?

When you have been sued or served, or a demand letter threatens suit: send it to the insurer that day, and speak to a Florida real estate attorney about any part of the claim the insurer says is not covered, since the insurer defends only the covered causes of action. Also when the insurer declines the claim, or offers less than you believe the loss is. Those are questions about your rights under a contract, and they are a lawyer's.

Common questions

Is there a deadline to make a claim?

The policy asks for written notice promptly once you know of the problem, and late notice reduces the insurer's liability only to the extent it was prejudiced. The 2021 form sets no fixed number of days for a proof of loss. Florida law sets time limits on lawsuits too, so a claim that has been declined should go to an attorney without delay.

Will making a claim raise my premium?

There is no premium to raise. An owner's policy is paid for once, at the closing, and stays in force without renewal.

Does my owner's policy cover a lien recorded after I bought?

Generally no. The policy excludes matters attaching or created after the policy date, and anything you created or agreed to, such as a contractor you hired. The exception is the gap between the closing and the recording of your deed, which Covered Risk 10 covers.

Does it cover a forged deed recorded after I bought?

Not on the standard owner's form: a forgery after the policy date is a matter created after it. The one before you bought is covered; this one is a different problem, with its own answer. Is home title theft a real risk in Florida, and do you need a title monitoring service?

I inherited the house. Does the owner's policy cover me?

It can. The policy's definition of the insured includes "the successor to the Title of an Insured by operation of law as distinguished from purchase, including heirs, devisees, survivors, personal representatives, or next of kin". A buyer from the estate needs a policy of their own.

I refinanced. Is my owner's policy still good?

Yes. It continues while you keep an estate or interest in the land (Condition 2), and a refinance does not change that. The new lender's policy protects the new lender.

Terms on this page

Each defined in a sentence or three, with the statute behind it, in the glossary of Florida title and closing terms.