The title search found something unusual. Who decides whether it can still be insured?

The title insurer does, on the specific file. Florida lets a commitment issue only once insurability has been determined from a reasonable title search under sound underwriting practices. Anything the search finds then becomes a requirement to clear before the closing, an exception the policy will not cover, or, by the insurer's decision, a matter it insures over.

Reviewed by Shevy Lowenstein, Florida Title Agent, License W766033November 16, 20266 min readSource: Bayit Title, https://bayittitle.com/title-problems/underwriter-insure-over-title-problem-florida

Does this stop the closing?

Only if it can neither be cleared nor insured over, and the insurer's answer is in writing before the closing either way.

Who decides
The title insurer, file by file
The usual route
Clearing it, not insuring over it
Cost to buyer
No change in premium, which is set by state rule
Needs a lawyer?
When it is contested, or a court has to act

Have a file with this on it?

Send us the address

What happens, in order

5 steps from search to resolution
  1. Step 1

    The search returns it

    A recorded matter, a gap in the chain, or a fact about the property that the record does not support.

  2. Step 2

    On the commitment

    Schedule B, Part I if it has to be cleared; Part II if the policy will not cover it.

  3. Step 3

    Can it be cleared?

    A payoff, a release, a court order, a corrective deed, an affidavit, a recorded easement.

  4. Step 4

    If not, the insurer decides

    Whether it will insure over the matter, and on what terms, in writing.

  5. Step 5

    The commitment is revised

    The requirement or exception comes off, or stays, before anyone signs.

Who this affects
Buyers, sellers and lenders on a file where the search returns something that an ordinary payoff or release will not clear.
Where it shows up
The title commitment: Schedule B, Part I (requirements) and Part II (exceptions).
Cost impact
None in premium. Florida title premiums are adopted by rule and apply throughout the state, and no one may knowingly charge a different one (Fla. Stat. § 627.780(1)). The cost of a difficult file is the work of clearing it.

Who decides whether a title can be insured?

The title insurer. Florida does not allow a commitment, endorsement or policy to be issued until the insurer "has caused to be made a determination of insurability based upon the evaluation of a reasonable title search", has examined "such other information as may be necessary", and has made that determination "in accordance with sound underwriting practices" (Fla. Stat. § 627.7845(1)).

A title agency does that work for the insurer. Florida defines it as an agency whose agents and employees "determine insurability in accordance with underwriting rules and standards prescribed by the title insurer represented by the agency", and issue commitments, endorsements and policies "on behalf of the appointing title insurer" (Fla. Stat. § 626.841(2)). Bayit Title's policies are underwritten by First American Title Insurance Company. On an ordinary file the search, the examination and the commitment are our work, under First American's rules. Where a matter calls for a decision those rules leave to the insurer, the decision is First American's, on that file.

What can a problem become on the commitment?

One of three things, and the commitment says which (ALTA Commitment, 2021):

  • A requirement, in Schedule B, Part I. Something that has to happen before the policy issues: a payoff and a satisfaction, a release, a court order, a corrective deed, a spouse's joinder, an affidavit. Most problems end here, and are cleared.
  • An exception, in Schedule B, Part II. A matter the policy will not cover. The rest of the policy stands; that matter is outside it.
  • A matter insured over. The insurer agrees to issue the policy without excepting it, so the insured is covered against loss from it even though it is still on the record.

The standard exceptions in Part II are narrower in Florida than the form alone suggests. A certified survey made within 90 days before the closing limits the survey exception to what the survey actually shows, and the seller's affidavits on possession and on recent unpaid work take out the exceptions for parties in possession and unrecorded construction liens, unless the insurer or agent knows facts that call for them and discloses them (Fla. Stat. § 627.7842(1)).

What does insuring over mean?

That the insurer has looked at a matter it could except, and decided to insure against loss from it instead. It does not remove the matter from the public record, and it does not decide whether the matter is valid. It moves the risk of it onto the insurer, within the terms of the policy.

Whether to do it, and on what terms, is the insurer's decision on the facts of the file.

It is the exception, not the rule. As the Florida title problems guide puts it, few problems can simply be insured over, and never by assumption: most are requirements, and they are cleared rather than insured over.

How are the problems on these pages usually resolved?

By clearing them. Each row below is what that page says, and the page is where the detail is:

The problem How it is ordinarily resolved Where the insurer comes in
A judgment against the seller Paid from the proceeds and satisfied, or shown to belong to someone else with an affidavit of identity Its written sign-off on the affidavit; whether it would ever insure over a judgment is decided file by file
A judgment against a homestead owner Homestead documented under oath, often with a notice of homestead The homestead position has to be documented in a form the insurer accepts
A lis pendens over money Withdrawn, or discharged by the court A requirement until it is gone; insuring over one is the insurer's decision on the file
A bankruptcy estate as seller The court's sale order, read as a title document Where the paper does not resolve it, an affirmative decision to insure over is one of the routes
No recorded legal access A recorded easement An access endorsement is an underwriting decision on the facts, and cannot create access the record lacks
An open permit Closing the permit with the municipality Not a coverage question: it is a municipal record, and the policy excludes building and zoning law
A seller signing abroad A deed signed so that it is recordable in the Florida county The deed has to be one the clerk will record and the insurer will insure

Does a riskier file cost more in premium?

No. The premium is adopted by rule, applies throughout the state, and may not knowingly be quoted, charged or collected at any other figure (Fla. Stat. §§ 627.782(1), (6), 627.780(1)). An unusual file pays the same premium as an ordinary one at the same price. What it costs is the work of clearing it: an attorney's time where a court has to act, a survey, a recorded document, and the days all of that takes.

When should an attorney be involved?

When it is contested, or when a court has to act. An estate that has not been through probate, a lawsuit or a lis pendens, a quiet title action, a boundary dispute, a judgment the seller disputes, a homestead question that is genuinely in doubt: each belongs with a Florida real estate attorney or the party's own counsel. We close alongside them and read what the court orders.

Common questions

Does an exception make the policy worthless?

No. An exception takes one matter out of the coverage; everything else the policy covers stays covered. It is still worth reading every exception in Schedule B, Part II before the closing, because each one is something the buyer is accepting.

Can a buyer ask for an exception to be removed?

Yes, by clearing what it is there for, and for the standard exceptions by giving the insurer what Florida law says it needs: a certified survey made within 90 days before the closing, and the seller's affidavits on possession and on unpaid work (Fla. Stat. § 627.7842(1)). Anything else is the insurer's decision on the file.

If the underwriter insures over something, is the problem fixed?

No. The matter is still on the record. The policy covers loss from it on its terms, for as long as the policy lasts. A buyer from you will be insured on a policy of their own, and that insurer decides for itself.

If First American declines, can another insurer be used?

We issue First American policies. Whether another insurer would take a matter First American has declined is that insurer's decision, through its own agent, on the same record.

Does the premium go up when the underwriter has to approve something?

No. The premium is set by state rule and is the same on a difficult file as on an ordinary one at the same price.

Terms on this page

Each defined in a sentence or three, with the statute behind it, in the glossary of Florida title and closing terms.

The Best of the Best. smooth, quick and professional. Shevy handled a complicated closing with liens and judgments and cleared it all in recorded time and didn't delay closing. Also she has amazing communication.

Mendel Sperlin · · Google review