Office hours: Monday – Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Call 754.253.2270
Bayit Title

5100 Bayview, Fisher Island: condominium rules, fees and closing points

5100 Bayview is a 22-unit Chapter 718 condominium in Building 51 on Fisher Island, run by 5100 Bayview at Fisher Island Condominium Association, Inc. A resale needs its estoppel as well as FICA's. It has no right of first refusal or lease approval; leases run at least six months, once a calendar year, and owners use 5000 Bayview's pool.

Reviewed by Shevy Lowenstein, Florida Title Agent, License W766033Recorded documents through October 29, 2004

The association at a glance

5100 Bayview at Fisher Island Condominium Association, Inc. — Chapter 718 condominium association

Second estoppel
5100 Bayview at Fisher Island Condominium Association, Inc., as well as FICA's
First refusal
None in the declaration or by-laws
Approval of a lease
None. The owner notifies the association of each tenancy (§ 17.8)
Leasing
Whole unit, at least six months, no more than one lease, renewals included, in a calendar year (§ 17.8)
Paid to it at closing
No transfer fee or capital contribution. A reasonable estoppel fee, and up to $150 plus copying and attorney's fees for information beyond what the law requires (By-Laws § 17)
Units
22 in Building 51 (unit numbers 5111–5171). The pool and generator are 5000 Bayview's, shared by unit count (§ 22)
Declaration
OR 22776/2676, recorded 29 October 2004 — the only 5100 Bayview instrument in our set
Manager
Not named in the documents we hold. Ask the association or FICA's office for the current manager; the estoppel, any right-of-first-refusal notice and any lease approval go through it. Source: the recorded declaration and the other documents in our set, checked October 5, 2026.

5100 Bayview at Fisher Island Condominium is one building of 22 units — Building 51, with unit numbers 5111 to 5171 — on part of Tract A-5 of Lindisfarne on Fisher Island Section 5 (Plat Book 137, Page 4). Five courses of its boundary run along the southerly boundary of Bayview No. Three (Declaration § 3.1 and Exhibit 1, OR 22776/2676). The exhibits label the building "Bayview Building No. 8", a surveyor's label rather than the condominium's name.

The declaration was made in October 2004 by Fisher Island Holdings, LLC, joined by the association, with the consents of Peabody Global Real Estate Partners, L.P. and Bank of America, N.A. as mortgagees, and recorded on 29 October 2004 (OR 22776/2676, CFN 2004R0957818). It is run by 5100 Bayview at Fisher Island Condominium Association, Inc. (§ 2.6). That declaration is the only 5100 Bayview instrument in our set. Nothing recorded after 29 October 2004 is in our set. It is on the same developer form as 5000 Bayview's, whose pool and emergency generator its owners use. Every owner is also a member of Fisher Island Community Association, Inc. ("FICA") (§ 23), so the Fisher Island master page applies as well. Nothing here replaces the association's estoppel certificate.

What does a closing here need beyond FICA's?

  • The association's estoppel. The declaration promises a certificate within fifteen (15) days of a written request by a purchaser, owner or mortgagee, for which the association "may charge a reasonable fee" (§ 13.7). Chapter 718 now requires it sooner: "Within 10 business days after receiving a written or electronic request therefor … the association shall issue the estoppel certificate" (Fla. Stat. § 718.116(8)(a)). The fee caps are on our page about HOA approvals and estoppels. FICA's estoppel is ordered separately (master page).
  • An information fee. For answering a prospective purchaser's or lienholder's requests beyond what the law requires, the association may charge a reasonable fee, which "shall not exceed $150.00 plus the reasonable cost of photocopying and any attorney's fees" (By-Laws § 17). No transfer fee, capital contribution or approval fee is set.
  • No right of first refusal, and no approval of the buyer. Neither appears in the declaration or the By-Laws. FICA approves no buyer either (master page).
  • Notice of the sale. Each owner files with the association "a copy of the deed or other document showing his ownership" (By-Laws § 11).
  • Entity buyers. Where a corporation owns a unit, the person who votes for it is designated by a certificate signed by an officer and filed with the association's Secretary (By-Laws § 3.6(c)).
  • Parking, golf-cart and storage assignments. These are limited common elements assigned in writing, "not recorded in the Public Records", with a copy kept by the association (§ 3.3(b)–(c)). Get the association's record of what goes with the unit. Owners accept that storage on the ground floor is below the federal flood plain (§ 3.3(b)).
  • The shared-facilities charge. The condominium pays a share of the costs of 5000 Bayview's pool and generator as a common expense (§ 22). Ask both associations how it is billed and whether anything is owed.

Can a unit here be leased?

Yes, on these terms (§ 17.8):

  • the whole unit only, under a written lease that lets the association terminate it if the tenant breaks the declaration or the rules;
  • "No Unit may be leased for a term of less than six (6) months and no Unit may be leased more than one (1) time, including any renewals, in any calendar year", counted by the date each lease or renewal commences;
  • the owner must notify the association "each and every time his Unit is to be occupied by a Tenant", and is jointly and severally liable for the tenant's violations;
  • the association may require an escrow deposit of a reasonable sum, "not to exceed the equivalent of one month's rental";
  • the same limits apply to subleases, assignments and renewals that change more than the end date and rent, and while the unit is leased the tenant, not the owner, has the use of the common facilities.

The declaration requires no approval of a lease or tenant. FICA's rules let it refuse a tenant the ferry only where an association approval is required and was not obtained, but tenants still register with FICA (master page). No leasing amendment is in our set. An amendment "prohibiting unit owners from renting their units or altering the duration of the rental term or specifying or limiting the number of times unit owners are entitled to rent their units during a specified period applies only to unit owners who consent to the amendment and unit owners who acquire title to their units after the effective date of that amendment" (Fla. Stat. § 718.110(13)), so for an investor buyer the records need searching forward from 2004.

What title points come up here?

  • The lien. Installments not paid within ten (10) days bear interest at "fifteen percent (15%) per annum" and a late fee of up to "the greater of $25.00 or five percent (5%)". The lien relates back to the recording of the declaration, but "as to first mortgages of record, the lien is effective from and after recording of a claim of lien" (§ 13.3). A claim of lien lasts one year unless suit is filed; each owner is deemed to assign the unit's rents to the association; and after 30 days' notice and a claim of lien the association may "accelerate and declare immediately due and payable all installments of Assessments for the remainder of the fiscal year" (§ 13.3).
  • The buyer owes what the seller did not pay. In a voluntary conveyance "the grantee shall be jointly and severally liable with the grantor for all unpaid Assessments" up to the conveyance (§ 13.1), and a unit owner "is jointly and severally liable with the previous owner for all unpaid assessments that came due up to the time of transfer of title" (Fla. Stat. § 718.116(1)(a)).
  • Bank-owned resales. Under the declaration a first mortgagee that takes title is liable for the lesser of six (6) months' assessments or "One percent (1%) of the original mortgage debt", and only if it joined the association in the foreclosure (§ 13.6). Chapter 718 now sets the limit at the lesser of the assessments "which accrued or came due during the 12 months immediately preceding the acquisition of title" or "One percent of the original mortgage debt" (§ 718.116(1)(b)1.). Which governs a sale is for underwriting.
  • Fines are capped at $100.00 per violation and $1,000.00 in the aggregate, after a committee hearing, and no fine is a lien (By-Laws § 5.1(m)).
  • The shared facilities rest on 5000 Bayview's declaration. Owners "shall have the right to use the emergency generator, and the pool, pool deck and accessory outdoor Common Element facilities" of 5000 Bayview, under a non-exclusive easement "set forth in the declaration of the Adjacent Condominium" (§ 22; 5000 Bayview Declaration § 22, OR 19711/2934). No separate cost-sharing agreement is in our set.
  • The developer's mortgages. Peabody Global Real Estate Partners, L.P. and Bank of America, N.A. consented to the declaration and subordinated their mortgages to it, but the declaration gives neither mortgage's recording data. Confirm a release of the unit from each in the chain.
  • Amending the declaration takes "in excess of 66 2/3% of the voting interests of all Unit Owners" (§ 6.1). An amendment directly affecting listed subjects, including "imposition of restrictions on leasing of units" and on "the selling or transferring of title to Units", also needs a Majority of Institutional First Mortgagees, whose consent may not be unreasonably withheld (§ 20.2). Special and capital-improvement assessments over $125,000.00 in a year, or raising the year's total above 115% of the year before, need a majority of the units at a meeting (§ 13.2(c)).
  • Cited but not in our set: the plat of Lindisfarne on Fisher Island Section 5 (PB 137/4), the two developer mortgages, and anything recorded after 29 October 2004. The only rules in our set are the 2004 Schedule "A" attached to the By-Laws; ask for the current rules.

What are the recorded documents?

Recorded Instrument What it did
29 Oct 2004 OR 22776/2676, CFN 2004R0957818 Declaration by Fisher Island Holdings, LLC, 88 pages, joined by the association, with the consents of Peabody Global Real Estate Partners, L.P. and Bank of America, N.A.; legal description, survey, share table for 22 units, By-Laws with the initial rules, and Articles; § 22 gives the owners the use of 5000 Bayview's pool and generator

Common questions

Does 5100 Bayview have a pool?

Its owners use 5000 Bayview's pool, pool deck, accessory outdoor facilities and emergency generator. The two associations share the costs, including reserves, by the number of units in each; 5000 Bayview's association regulates the pool, but "no such regulation shall discriminate against Unit Owners" of 5100 Bayview (§ 22).

Can I rent out my 5100 Bayview unit?

Yes, without the association's approval, for at least six months, with no more than one lease, renewals included, in a calendar year, and with notice to the association each time (§ 17.8). The leasing section above has the detail.

What fees does the association charge on a sale?

None is set beyond a reasonable estoppel fee (§ 13.7) and, for information beyond what the law requires, a fee of no more than $150.00 plus copying and attorney's fees (By-Laws § 17). FICA's estoppel fee is separate.

Are pets allowed?

Household pets are allowed with no stated number, if permitted by law, not left unattended on balconies or lanais, and not a nuisance. Pets must be leashed (no more than six feet) outside the unit, and no reptiles or wildlife may be kept (§ 17.3).

Can I put in tile or wood floors?

Hard surface flooring is allowed only where the sound isolation carries a minimum Sound Transmission Classification (STC) of 50, and heavy improvements need the Board's approval (§ 17.9).

Who is responsible for the hurricane shutters?

The developer provided shutters for the parts of the building that needed them, and the association is "solely responsible for the installation of hurricane shutters from time to time" as a common expense. Shutters stay open until a storm watch or warning is announced, and an owner who will be away in hurricane season must name a responsible firm or person to the association (§ 17.12).

Is a private elevator part of my unit?

Yes. "Any elevators (including all mechanical equipment serving, and housing for the elevators) solely serving a Unit (to the exclusion of all other Units) shall be deemed part of the Unit" (§ 3.2(c)).

Elsewhere in Fisher Island